Like “The Little Glass Bottle,” both “The Mystery of the Grave-Yard” and “The Secret Cave (or, John Lee’s Adventure)” were written by Lovecraft some time in 1898. Again, I don’t think it’d be right to offer scathing literary criticism of the work of an eight year old, so don’t think of this an actual review, so much as my brief thoughts and reflections.
One day a young man rushed in and exclaimed “The secret Is revealed!” and was gone.
“The Mystery of the Grave-Yard” is clearly inspired by Victorian-era detective fiction like Sherlock Holmes. The hero of the story, named King John, is a detective called in to investigate the disappearance of Mr. Dobson. Dobson disappeared during the funeral of a Joseph Burns while following the late Mr. Burns’s instructions to descend into the tomb before interrment and drop a ball onto a spot marked “A.” After a John Bell appears to demand ransom for the return of Dobson, King John arrests him and and his accomplice. At the trial, Dobson makes his dramatic reappearance, having escaped from his prison by making a wax impression of the key (and thereby doing a respectable McGuyver impersonation a good eighty years before anyone had even heard of McGuyver). Dobson reveals the mastermind of his kidnapping, Francis Burns, the brother of the late Joseph Burns, both of whom had plotted to do harm to Dobson for years for reasons unrevealed. The villains are punished, King John marries Dobson’s daughter, and the rest live happily ever after.
Truth be told, I had a hard time following this little tale, and I suspect few people actually managed to make sense of the above summary. But it’s definitely an ambitious little story, and shows how clever and imaginative Lovecraft was even at this young age. As I mentioned above, there’s a definite Sherlock Holmes vibe to the story, and it shows an affinity for the pulp fiction Lovecraft would later make his name writing. We still haven’t gotten any real horror fiction from him, but the appearance of the titular “grave-yard” is a good sign.
“Now be good children” Said Mrs. Lee “While I am away & dont get into mischief”
Next up is “The Secret Cave,” another pulpish adventure story from grade-school-age Lovecraft. Mr. and Mrs. Lee go out on the town and leave their two children, the ten year old John and the two year old Alice, to amuse themselves. John and Alice find a hidden passage in their cellar and decide to go exploring. In the passage, they find a mysterious sealed box, a boat, and an obstacle. Too curious for his own good, John removes the obstacle and unleashes a torrent of water that drowns his sister and almost drowns him. To show that the universe isn’t wholly without pity, however, John opens the sealed box after Alice’s funeral and finds a chunk of gold worth $10,000 “enough to pay for anything but the death of his sister.”
Well, “The Secret Cave” is certainly easier to follow than “The Mystery of the Grave-Yard,” but, wow, is that ending dark or what? The “box full of money” ending is essentially the same twist as we saw in “The Little Glass Bottle.” In both cases, the money is insufficient to fully offset the loss incurred obtaining it, even if it does take a bit of the edge off. It’s a bit morbid, but it’s not horror.
Incidentally (and apropos of nothing), I was curious enough at the $10,000 figure to go and do a calculation regarding the comparative purchasing power of $10,000 in 1898 and today. Apparently, $10,000 in 1898 money is equivalent to $257,888.06 in 2007 (which is the latest year available for the calculations at Measuring Worth).
Well, that concludes our brief look at Lovecraft’s “juvenilia.” It took me longer than it should have, and I suspect it wasn’t all that interesting to read my non-reviews. Next up I’ll be looking at “The Alchemist,” written in 1908, and the gloves are coming off. I’m looking forward to it, and I hope to have my review up by the end of the week.